Jingle those bells and deck the halls, it’s time for church Christmas songs! Worship leaders rejoice, the season is nigh to mix beloved tradition with creative new spins. Let familiar carols ring, then surprise with a modern remix. Lean into nostalgia with classics like “Silent Night,” then get everyone on their feet with high energy anthems. It’s a tricky balance to strike, but with Chris Tomlin, Hillsong, and more, these top picks check all the boxes. They’ll have congregations cheering “Joy to the World” as you seamlessly blend old and new. This December, curate the ultimate setlist that honors the past while looking to the future.